
Dubai Court of Cassation Confirms Flexible Compensation for Personal Injuries Beyond Strict Diya Limits
Dubai Court of Cassation rejects insurance company’s appeal and confirms AED 200,000 compensation for traffic accident victims. In its judgment dated 1 November 2018 (Appeal No. 330 of 2018 Civil), the Court held that judges are not strictly bound by the fixed amounts of diya or arsh provided under Islamic law in assessing compensation for bodily injuries.
The Civil Transactions Law empowers courts to grant greater sums based on the actual damages suffered. The ruling affirms the direct right of injured third parties against compulsory motor insurers.
Background of the Dispute
- The claimant was seriously injured in an accident that occurred due to a road traffic accident on 14 January 2014, in which the car involved was insured by the respondent insurance company.
- The driver who was driving the insured car was found guilty of the accident by a final criminal judgment in Case 346 of 2014 (Traffic Misdemeanours and Violations – Dubai).
- The claimant filed a civil suit requesting compensation of AED 500,000 for physical, material, and moral damages along with interest.
- The Court of First Instance initially awarded AED 100,000. After appeals and a cassation referral due to jurisdictional issues, the matter was reheard by the full civil court.
- On 30 October 2017, the first instance court ordered the insurance company and the driver to compensate AED 200,000 plus 9% annual interest.
- The insurance company appealed in the Civil Appeal Case No. 1586 of 2017. The appeal court approved the order on 27 May 2018.
- The insurance company then filed a cassation appeal (Case No. 330 of 2018).
What the Dubai Courts Decided
The Court of First Instance and the Court of Appeal decided that the insurance company is liable for AED 200,000 compensation.
The Court of Cassation upheld the decisions of the lower courts and dismissed the appeal of the insurance company entirely.
The Court of Cassation rejected the following arguments put forward by the insurance company:
- That the amount of compensation should be restricted to the fixed diya/arsh amounts based on Sharia law (half of diya for 60% disability of one leg – AED 60,000)
- That the award was arbitrary and excessive
- That the insurance company was not liable as the driver lacked a UAE driving licence
- That the insurance company was not informed about the accident in time
Key Findings of the Court of Cassation
The Court applied the provisions of the Civil Transactions Law (especially Articles 292 and 299), together with those of the compulsory motor insurance law (Law No. 21 of 1995 and its Executive Regulations). The Court found that:
The Court ruled that:
- The injured third party has a right against the compulsory motor insurance company as stipulated under the law. The insurer cannot use exceptions arising out of contracts between them, such as not having a license to drive or failure to notify.
- Judges are not required to restrict themselves to the fixed diya/arsh amounts specified under Islamic law for their calculations. Once a civil law provision is in force, its provisions have to be applied. Judges can award additional compensation commensurate with the total damage sustained (physical and psychological).
- Article 299 of the Civil Transactions Law prevents claiming the same damages twice by claiming both diya/arsh and civil compensation in respect of the same personal injuries. This does not mean that the court is barred from granting civil compensation that exceeds the amounts traditionally awarded as diya.
- The amount of compensation for bodily and moral damage will be factual and at the discretion of the courts, as long as they determine the elements of damage.
Key Takeaways for Insurance Companies and Claimants in Dubai
- The compulsory motor insurer cannot avoid paying compensation to the injured third party through any policy exceptions or the absence of a license of the driver.
- There is wide discretion available to award compensation higher than the traditional diya/arsh compensation where the actual harm justifies it.
- Serious disabilities (such as in this case where there was a 60% permanent disability of the right lower limb) can provide a sound basis for higher awards.
- The medical reports (for instance from the Higher Medical Liability Committee) carry high evidentiary value.
- Interest may be awarded from the time of the judgment becoming final.
Conclusion
This case law offers much-needed guidance on the relationship between fixed Islamic compensation (diya/arsh) and modern civil compensation for personal injuries in traffic accidents. It clearly establishes that Dubai courts give priority to full compensation for damage based on the provisions of the Civil Transactions Law, without undermining the basic principles of Sharia.
For insurance companies, the decision outlines that third-party beneficiaries are given wide protection under the compulsory motor insurance scheme. For victims, it clearly states that courts are capable of awarding reasonable compensation for severe life disabilities.
Disclaimer: This summary is based only on the Dubai Court of Cassation judgment issued on 1 November 2018 in Cassation Appeal No. 330 of 2018 (Civil). Readers should refer to the official judgment for full details. This summary is for information only and is not legal advice.
