Home / Judgments / Dubai Court of Cassation Confirms Enforcement of Foreign FOSFA Arbitration Award
Dubai Court of Cassation Confirms Enforcement of Foreign FOSFA Arbitration Award

An Overview

The Dubai Court of Cassation has rejected two commercial appeals and maintained the enforcement of a foreign arbitral award made by the Federation of Oils, Seeds and Fats Associations (FOSFA) in London. In the judgment issued on 11 September 2025, the Court stated that the award meets the requirements of the New York Convention and is thus enforceable in the UAE. The decision underscores the limited grounds on which Dubai courts can question foreign arbitration awards.

Background of the Dispute

    • On 28 August 2024, a company secured a final arbitral award from FOSFA in London in arbitration case No. 1208. This award concerned the commercial contracts for the supply of sunflower oil. 
    • The successful party applied to the Dubai courts for the recognition and enforcement of the award so that it could be executed in the UAE.
    • On 14 March 2025, the Dubai execution judge granted the request and ordered that the executive formula be placed on the foreign award. The other party challenged that decision before the Dubai Court of Appeal (Appeal No. 8 of 2025). 
    • On 17 June 2025, the Court of Appeal upheld the enforcement order. 
  • The opposing party then filed two separate cassation appeals (Nos. 778 and 887 of 2025 Commercial). 
  • The Court of Cassation joined the two appeals and heard them together.

What the Dubai Courts Decided

The execution judge granted the request for recognition and enforcement of the award. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision.

The Court of Cassation dismissed both appeals and confirmed the Court of Appeal’s ruling. As a result, the FOSFA award remains enforceable in Dubai.

The Court of Cassation rejected all the arguments raised against enforcement of the award, including:

  • Alleged defects in the signature of the award (signed only by the chairman of the arbitral tribunal on the last page)
  • Claims that the award of compound interest violated UAE public policy
  • Arguments that no valid contracts or arbitration agreement existed between the parties
  • Challenges to the jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal
  • Attempts to re-open issues already decided in earlier final judgments of the Dubai courts

Key Findings of the Court of Cassation

The Court applied the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards. The UAE became a party to this Convention through Federal Decree No. 43 of 2006. Under UAE law (Articles 222 and 225 of the Civil Procedure Law), the New York Convention has priority. This means that when courts review requests to enforce arbitral awards, they follow the rules of the Convention first.

The Court held that:

  • Dubai courts conduct only a limited review under Article V of the New York Convention. They examine whether any of the specific grounds for refusal exist. They have no power to annul the foreign award or to re-examine the merits of the dispute.
  • Refusal reasons of public policy under Article V(2) are interpreted narrowly. The method of award signature and the granting of compound interest did not constitute a violation of UAE public policy.
  • Final judgments of Dubai courts established the doctrine of res judicata. The opposing party had already asserted the same arguments concerning the contracts and arbitration agreement in the previous proceeding, and those arguments were rejected. Thus, they could not be raised once again at enforcement.
  • The enforcing party must provide all documents required under Article IV of the New York Convention. Thus, the burden of proof regarding refusal reasons under Article V fell on the opposing party, which failed to prove it.

Key Takeaways for Businesses and Arbitration Parties in Dubai

  • Foreign arbitral awards that meet the requirements of the New York Convention can be enforced in Dubai.
  • A challenge to enforcement on purely formal grounds (such as signature) shall be dismissed unless it clearly falls within one of the restricted grounds of the Convention.
  • Application of public policy in international commercial arbitration is restrictive.
  • A matter which has been finally determined by a Dubai court cannot be re-examined in later enforcement proceedings.
  • Upon submission of the documents required under Article IV of the Convention by the party enforcing the award, it is for the opposing party to prove the existence of one of the grounds for refusal provided in Article V of the Convention.
  • The Dubai courts can recognize and enforce international awards issued by recognized international institutions within an efficient time frame.
  • Dubai courts are supportive of efficient enforcement of awards by international institutions like FOSFA.

What the Judgment Means

The ruling provides clear guidance on the enforcement of foreign awards in Dubai courts. The decision underlines the commitment of the UAE to arbitration and that Dubai courts have only a limited role in enforcing foreign awards pursuant to the New York Convention.

Companies that conduct business in international trade will be able to enforce foreign awards in Dubai as long as they follow the requirements of the Convention. Any party that is contesting the enforcement of such awards will only rely on grounds of refusal as specified in the Convention and cannot repeat arguments already rejected in earlier final judgments.

The judgment reinforces the need to have clearly drafted agreements from the start.

 

Disclaimer: This summary is based only on the Dubai Court of Cassation judgment issued on 11 September 2025 in Cassation Appeals Nos. 778 and 887 of 2025 (Commercial). Readers should refer to the official judgment for full details. This summary is for information only and is not legal advice.